JediDefender.com Forums

Community => Site Feedback, Suggestions, and Help => Topic started by: Nathan on July 3, 2005, 01:17 AM

Title: Combining Expanded Universe forum and Jocasta's Reading Room?
Post by: Nathan on July 3, 2005, 01:17 AM

How come there are two separate EU forums? Essentially the same things are being discussed in both, so it seems to add an unnecessary level of complication.

The description on the Expanded Universe forum is
"Discuss everything relating to Star Wars EU"

And Jocasta's Reading Room is
"Give your opinion on Star Wars books and comics"

which is merely a subset of the other one.

If it was up to me I'd merge the two and keep the Jocasta's Reading Room title. There's only 68 threads between the two of them.


<7/4 edit: Corrected the number of threads, due to erroneous adding previously.>

Title: Re: Combining Expanded Universe forum and Jocasta's Reading Room?
Post by: JesseVader08 on July 3, 2005, 12:29 PM

Thanks for the suggestion, Nathan.  It's certainly something worth looking into, so we'll let everyone know what is decided after a little discussion.

 :)

Title: Re: Combining Expanded Universe forum and Jocasta's Reading Room?
Post by: JediMAC on July 7, 2005, 12:24 AM

I see that brilliant minds think alike, Nathan.  I've been contemplating doing exactly what you're suggesting there, for several weeks now.  Running it past the crew behind the scenes right now, so we'll see what turns up...  ;)

Granted, I think that the "EU" portion is more a subset of the Book (Jocasta) section really, if you're including all the reference types of materials on the films and collectibles, and stuff like magazines and whatnot.  I basically view "EU" as Star Wars fiction, for the most part, which definitely falls under books.  But I don't think the aforementioned "reference" type of books necessarily fall under "EU" though, like Sansweet's "Action Figure Archive" book, or the coffee table Star Wars Chronicles reference book, or the recent magazines covering the ROTS movie, etc...

Anyway, stay tuned, and we'll figure something out for this, 'cause I agree that it's confusing, and for the most part, repetitive.

- M

Title: Re: Combining Expanded Universe forum and Jocasta's Reading Room?
Post by: Nathan on February 1, 2006, 12:07 AM

Quote from: JesseVader08 on July  3, 2005, 12:29 PM

Thanks for the suggestion, Nathan.  It's certainly something worth looking into, so we'll let everyone know what is decided after a little discussion.

 :)

*blows dust off the thread*

Soooooo ... was the consensus "No", or did this critically important matter ;) simply slip through the cracks? Any news on this front?

Title: Re: Combining Expanded Universe forum and Jocasta's Reading Room?
Post by: Jesse James on February 1, 2006, 12:26 AM

I've been wanting to condense some EU stuff actually so hopefully we'll see an answer soon.  I think I'd like to see the blanket EU forum fold under Jocasta's to encompass reading material, and see our EU area between the trilogies encompass more than Television EU since "EU" Covers SOoooooooo much beyond books, comics, video games, RPG's, Television programs, etc.

Title: Re: Combining Expanded Universe forum and Jocasta's Reading Room?
Post by: Reid on February 1, 2006, 08:41 PM

I'm all for it. We could call it Jocasta's Universe Of Expanded Reading Rooms.

Title: Re: Combining Expanded Universe forum and Jocasta's Reading Room?
Post by: JediMAC on February 1, 2006, 10:18 PM

Quote from: Valin Kenobirific! on February  1, 2006, 12:07 AM

Soooooo ... was the consensus "No", or did this critically important matter ;) simply slip through the cracks? Any news on this front?

The consensus was that we couldn't agree on how to do it, unfortunately, so we left it as it was for the time being.  But they're talking about it again right now, so maybe the results will be better this time through...