Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Phantom-like Menace

Pages: 1 [2]
16
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars Series Discussion Thread
« on: December 5, 2008, 02:28 AM »
Newsarama has a short clip up from this week's episode "Cloak of Darkness".

The description of the scene is that Unduli gives Padawad (sic) Ahsoka Tano guidance. I saw no guidance (and certainly no "Padawad").

17
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars Series Discussion Thread
« on: November 23, 2008, 08:18 PM »
I think the episode suffered from not being straight-up comedy. Kevin Rubio's involvement made me think it would be laugh a minute. I didn't really smile at anything, let alone laugh. I don't think it was even intended to be funny per se, but just have some funny moments. I thought it was going to be funny with maybe some serious moments.

18
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars Series Discussion Thread
« on: November 21, 2008, 01:07 AM »
I enjoyed the fight between Ahsoka and Grievous. I laughed when she cut Grievous' hand off. He's really got to watch that. They did a good job balancing making her seem like she didn't have a chance but still getting away. It was also enjoyable when she dropped into the fight at the end and took out the droid starfighters.

Of course Artoo got to kick a little butt. At first I thought it was going to be cutesy, but as soon as Goldie started to fall and fired his grapple onto Artoo, I knew Artoo was about to cut him loose and send him to the Maker. Loved Anakin's last minute save. Cliche, but welcome.

19
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars Series Discussion Thread
« on: November 14, 2008, 02:02 AM »
I didn't think it was too unbelievable that the AT-TEs could inflict enough damage to give Anakin's forces the upper hand. There were a great number of them (you can see fire coming from other asteroids off screen as well), and they were firing into unprotected, possibly sensitive areas like the engines, and it's possible they could even have taken out the shield generators and that the cruisers did most of the damage after that. I found it less believable that one of Anakin's cruisers gets knocked out so easily. I also agree that the time constraints of the show prevented the scene from running longer.

So not much to comment on this episode. I really liked the creative thinking that went into the AT-TE ambush. Kudos to whichever writer came up with that. I liked that we continue to see Ahsoka giving Anakin much needed advice. It's a shame something as simple as nicknames cause fans to discount her character's strengths. The IG assassin droid attack was cool, and I thought Ahsoka's bisecting the droid straight out from a flip was awesome. I did like seeing Artoo's escape attempt as well.

Otherwise, kind of a dull episode.

20
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars Series Discussion Thread
« on: November 3, 2008, 07:09 AM »
Well, at least we learn why it is that Obi-Wan wouldn't recognize R2 in Episode IV. He's gone through so many astromechs, that he refuses to believe one survived.

21
Jocasta's Reading Room / Re: Republic Commando
« on: November 1, 2008, 11:21 AM »
Wow, for such a great series, I can't believe this thread gets so little traffic.

I should warn, there are SPOILERS for the entire series here.









I liked the first book, managed to get through the second, thought the third was great, and really enjoyed the fourth.

The RCs were all interesting enough, and Kal and Vau were straight up awesome. I was usually a little annoyed by Etain. I think her character would have been better served by the author if she had left the Order before or instead of Bardan. As it is, she kind of just went through the series with a target painted on her. It seemed like she had to stay with the Order just to die at the end.

I know a lot of people have a problem with the idea that there are so many Mandalorians running around in full armor when some sources said Boba was one of the last of his kind. I'm not really sure of the original source of this thinking, but I figure enough sources have implied there are more of them (going back as far as the Marvel run with Fenn Shysa and Tobbi Dala and including MandalMotors in Dark Horse, and new sources like Traviss's books) to allow that the original source of this idea might be discountable. Otherwise, I'm a Mandalorian dork, so I'm happy to see them all.

I was really happy to read in Order 66 that Jango knew full well the clone army was being made to kill the Jedi, and that that was the reason he allowed himself to be cloned, because he wanted revenge on the Jedi.

Otherwise, yes, Traviss is supposed to be writing Imperial Commando: 501st, which is set for August of 2009. I was a little worried when Order 66 left so much up in the air, so I looked into it and saw there were more books planned, at least two in the future.

22
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars Series Discussion Thread
« on: November 1, 2008, 10:38 AM »
I'm a little late to the discussion, but I had some thoughts about Shadow of Malevolence, the episode where Anakin leads the Y-wing squadron in the run on Malevolence. I had originally posted this on another site, and I'm copying and pasting it here if anyone has any thought about it.

I really liked this episode. There was a lot going on between Koon, Anakin, and Ahsoka. I'm not sure Koon isn't just undermining Anakin's authority with Ahsoka and needs to keep some things to himself. But I liked that Ahsoka pointed out to Anakin that just because he can surivive in crazy odds doesn't mean his men can. It's a lesson that's hard for Anakin to accept, and I think it very nicely showed that learning in a master and apprentice relationship runs both ways.

23
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars Series Discussion Thread
« on: October 31, 2008, 05:41 PM »
Anyone catch the "Allied Armed Forces Radio" kinda thing they had going on with the holo-chick playing music and the Clones listening?  Very neat...  Reminded me of Tokyo Rose and the like.  It'd be neat to hear a Separatist one doing some mind-******* with the Clones or something.

The WWII references are great. I'm a big history buff, and I love WWII, especially the Pacific Theater. As for the Separatists screwing with the clones, I just pictured two clones listening to a battle droid DJ tell them their girlfriends are back home sleeping with their brothers, and the two of them just looking at each other confused. It also makes me think of the line from Saving Private Ryan: (paraphrased) He just said the Statue of Liberty is kaput. It would be cool to see either way.

24
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars Series Discussion Thread
« on: October 31, 2008, 02:35 AM »
I've been enjoying the series well enough.

I agree with those who feel the clones are really great in this series. I actually think they need to either do more with Cody and Rex or make more clones series regulars. Or, I suppose if they got really crazy they could make non-clone characters more interesting.

I don't have the problem with Ahsoka some people on the Internet seem to have. As mentioned, are the nicknames annoying? Sure. Can I ignore them? Sure. She's not one-tenth as annoying as Jar-Jar. I'm really interested in finding out what happens to her character. I hope she survives Order 66 and goes one on one with Vader. I think they could really do something great with that.

Individually, I've liked all of the episodes, but I think the Malevolence storyline stuck around an episode too long for me. One of those (don't feel like looking to decide which) was my least favorite so far, and my favorite has been Rookies. I loved the line, "Heavy really did hate that place." Rex and Cody got laughs out of me as Rex tried to impersonate a commando droid to get into the outpost.

I pretty much signed up here at JediDefender because it seems like this is one of the few places I can discuss the show without wading through senseless bashing. I can't even talk to my off-line friends about it, because they're stuck in the "Worst Star Wars Ever," "Killing Star Wars," Never Watching Star Wars Again" mindsets that make it nearly impossible to even discuss what I don't like about the show let alone what I do like about it.

Edit: Oh, I forgot to mention that I will be upset if this show doesn't have some Republic Commandos in it, preferably soon. There is some indication that the two scouts who reported the location of the Teth Monestary were Kom'rk and Jaing, two of the Null ARCs from Traviss's books but I don't know if that was the initial intent or if it was decided retroactively.

Pages: 1 [2]