Honestly, no. I never get in to the debate of movie version vs. photo prop and don't intend to now. The scale of the doll versus the size of the saber looks fine to me. Also, the saber itself looks just like the one in the movie. I can't tell when they do a close up Luke's saber that it is any different from the shot of him swinging away with it on the sail barge. No disrespect to anyone with my answer, it's just my opinion.
As for the tip of the blade, well that doesn't really sway me one way or the other. I am use to the Hasbro version but I am flexible enough to have the "pointy" version. I am more concerned with the character's facial features above all else. If that blows, it makes no difference to me if the clothes, saber or anything else is spot on.