I finally made my choice, and I chose Darth Malak. This was a tough poll, because I think there were a number of good choices. Here's my methodology...
The Clones - Both of these Clones are bound to be made. Hasbro has come to recognize just how much of a market there is for Clone Troopers, so I think that both Commander Neyo and the Galactic Marine are bound to be made by Hasbro within at least the next couple of years.
Luke Throne Room Duel - This figure has got to be in the pipeline. There's been enough whining and complaining about it that it's bound to be made in a form that's similar to that of the VOTC line. Just give it some time.
Ultimate Darth Maul - This figure's already been done in the Sith Lords Evolution set.
Kir Kanos - The rumors have been around since last year that this is going to be an Entertainment Earth exclusive. Why waste the vote?
Quinlan Vos - Out of all of the EU figures, I think this one has the best likelihood of being made.
Clone Wars Padme - I think the Clone Wars animated line has some legs. The demand for the WalMart 3-packs was pretty serious. There are bound to be some more Clone Wars animated figures at some point, and I think Padme is bound to be part of that.
Padme in black leather - Uhhhh... why does this sound like a fanboy's disgusting little fantasy? Just the seediness of this makes me turn away from it.
Dead Padme - Yeah, this is what we need. An action figure of a CORPSE. An action figure of a woman who died in childbirth. How pleasant.
The NJO characters - I hate to lump them all together, but I really have no connection with the NJO characters. As such I can't invest the vote with these characters.
Kyle Katarn - We already have a Kyle Katarn. Do we really need another?
Mara Jade Skywalker - Same deal as Kyle Katarn. I'd rather have an all new figure than another version of a character that I don't read that much about.
Corran Horn - I seriously thought about voting for Horn. I've heard the name over and over again, but the thing is, I haven't read a single thing featuring Corran Horn. Haven't read about you, not voting for you. Sorry dude.
Hermi Odle - This figure very nearly got my vote. I think that a fan poll would put this figure over the top. In fact, I think this one may win the poll, or at the very least get some serious consideration from Hasbro at some point in time. I decided to invest my vote otherwise.
Yarna d'al Gargan - There have been a lot of calls for this figure over the years. Why, I don't know. This is quite possibly the ugliest character ever in the Star Wars universe. And franky, I don't want to get that vomit taste in my mouth when I look at my Jabba's palace diorama.
Ice Cream Maker Guy - I know there's been a buzz about this guy from a number of collectors on a number of forums. But you know what? It's not even a choice for me. It's kitschy and weird, but seriously, this is like having a Marvel Avengers or Fantastic Four toy line and having a Willie Lumpkin (the mailman) figure. It's become an inside joke and just isn't that funny, just as most inside jokes aren't funny.
The KOTOR characters - This is where I decided to invest my vote. I weighed the choices pretty well. There's Darth Nihilus. He's an incredibly cool looking character. But he doesn't seem that important in the grand scheme of KOTOR II. Darth Sion seems like a better choice, but he didn't even make the finals. HK-47 is cool, but definitely an ancillary character. Bastilla is cool, but not as important a character as the two Sith lords in this game. Revan? You ARE Revan if you've ever played KOTOR. Thing is you just don't know it until late in the game, and the character isn't readily identifiable since there are a number of variables you can choose in building your player character. The only option is to choose Revan as his Dark Lord persona with a mask. You only get to see that in flashbacks. With all of that in mind, I chose Darth Malak. He seems like the most identifiable of the KOTOR characters. Here's hoping that he wins.