I was just just reading some reactions
over at IGN as well, and it seems similar to here - sort of mixed to "meh". Like I said, I've personally never seen a 3D movie - and those who have seem to say the ones that are converted later aren't anything too great. That said, for all of Lucas' detractors, you can't say the guy skimps on the tech side of things. I'm sure it will look as good as it possibly can, at least for that time.
Like we've discussed here already, I'm excited just for the fact that they'll be in theaters again. Heck, I think I'd be about as excited if they were just doing a straight re-release (even if it was just the OT). Like Jesse said, to experience the Trilogy (or the Saga) on the big screen again is spiffy enough. Although I can see why they are starting with TPM, it makes you wonder if they shouldn't have started with the OT. That's likely what everyone is "waiting for" the most anyways, and who knows what will change/advance in movie viewing in the time following TPM's re-release. It is sort of funny to see such a lukewarm reaction to news that has been talked about for so long now. I don't know if it is the general apathy towards 3D in general (likely), or if it is just people not caring about Star Wars as much anymore. Like I said, I'll be there - likely for all of them - but I would be if they were just doing straight re-releases as well.