Nobody's talking about the R2 because Hasbro already said they reproportioned it... If anyone else is like me, they're not pleased about that seeing as how Hasbro did a bajillion Astromechs one size, and now with this R2 they're doing one that is going to be very oddly sized by comparison I am afraid.
The Luke... Eh. I wasn't that bothered by last years ROTJ Luke. Some were flipping lids, but to me I liked it. This is far superior looking in proportions, but maybe it's the fact it's coming out so soon that people are just maybe irked they bought last years? It's a mostly mish-mash of parts, isn't it? Not really a lot of new tooling. At least I thought it looked like a mix of parts and a new head to me.
For me, the top 3 figures were GamGuard, Endor Rebel, and Ackbar... Not much else compared, even though it was still nice... The GamGuard is one of their finest figures I think.