I love the design a lot, just not a fan of the toy. After I was sorta burned by the AT-DP's quality, I'm suspicious of this one's ultimate in-person quality as well. For the price and all, it's just a tough pill these days.
I found the TIE Advanced to be the best of the lot actually. I thought it had the most sturdy build, most detail, most complexity in its design... I didn't get The Phantom however, but I did look it over and I wasn't impressed.
It's definitely closer to a 1/35-ish scale (ala Kubies).