Okay, this post is full of spoilers, so anyone who doesn't want to find anything out about Seasons 1 and 2, please click away now, as I relinquish all responsibility from this sentence on.
Am I the only one who's been thinking of Kimber all along? My memories of last season are fuzzy--she was never attacked by the Carver was she?
I had initially ignored the possibility that Kimber was a suspect due to the physical strength issues, but now that I've rewatched Season 2 on DVD, I'm thinking that it could be her, since all the victims we've seen were drugged prior to their attack and/or rape. Kimber would definitely have motive (her looks have been a curse more than a blessing) and she would have access to some potent drugs due to her own habit and/or time spent living with the already-dubious Merrill Bobolit. And then, hey, she's shown she's kinky enough to have strap-on dildos laying around the house, so there you go.
My first suspect was Liz, since the Carver victims started to show up right around the time she had the abortion. She told Christian that she wanted "one of the parents to be beautiful" and she had often been the staunch anti-plastic surgery spokesperson around office, often belittling Sean and Christian for doing boob jobs and tummy tucks for vain women with a lot of money. She had access to the drugs, she had knowledge of physiology, and she had a personal motive (the hatred of outside being more than the inside), but at the same time, the Carver was "getting back" at Sean for "correcting his work", pro bono, and since that's something Liz supported (the pro bono work for people who actually needed surgery), I don't know how they could reconcile the disparity.
At this point, I think it's easier to figure out who ISN'T the Carver than it is to figure out who IS. With that in mind, here's who I've disqualified from the race:
-Christian (for obvious reasons)
-Quentin Costa (he's been otherwise engaged in Atlanta)
-Annie McNamara (she's nine)
-Adrian Moore (he's dead)
I wonder if this is how my mom felt when J.R. got shot?