Not good enough, especially with the price hike... New figure or nothing.
The old one's sculpt is poor IMO with the caved in chest, pre-posed arms, etc... I'd sooner see a SA one. From what I've seen though, the Tantive IV's crew isn't the same as in ANH. It's possible Lucas is actually adhering to EU that the T4's manned by actual Rebel soldiers, and that is their uniform in ANH, and whoever mans it in ROTS is different... Or uniforms change over time.
On the figure though, if they did have FT's in ROTS, I'd be all for a new, Collection 2 Super articulated one with Antilles' helmet and blaster, and a working holster.
Oh, and a pliable removable vest that actually comes off easily. Given what the other Col.2 figures look like (or seem to), this would easily be on my wish list whether it's ROTS or ANH. I don't think the uni's will be the same, for whatever reason though, judging by what I've seen of I believe to be the ship's pilot(s) in actually the recent Insider.