Ok, the pitching scoring really is seriously ****** up. I had a guy win last night (capuano). Yes, he gave up six runs, but his score for the night was -4 points That's seriously retarded. A win should override the negative stuff.
In other news, Carpenter has pretty much thrown away the Cy Young award
Yup, Scott's scoring system when he was commish in year 1 was a win 5 points, K 1 point, ER minus 1, and BB minus 1.
I posted in the thread for recommendations when I was commish for year 2, and there weren't many, but I did increase a win from 5 points to 7 points.
Perhaps next year a win should be 12.
If you look at my W-L ratio and K's, I have one of the best W-L records at 71-47 and the most K's. It wouldn't have made a difference anyhow.