Likely a pass for me as well, unless I buy one just for novelty's sake. If they had made them more like traditional Transformers, and not tried to make the SW ships look like "characters" so much, I think they would be better received. That said, the kids (and TF collectors) might love them. I know that one of our nephews really likes anything relating to Transformers. I know I probably would have found them pretty cool when I was a kid, at the height of SW and Transformer (Gen 1) popularity.