I've had my Y-Wing since mid-August and I share many of the sentiments already echoed. In short, I like the ship, but feel that more could have been done with it for the price point. I see it as an example of Hasbro moving in the right direction - making larger vehicles with greater amounts of realistic detail - but the ship fell short from what it could have been in many respects. For one, the paint job could have used more weathering and coloration. Other Hasbro ships have that, including contemporary releases like Wedge's X-Wing at Target. The Y-Wing just screams white and yellow, almost to the point of being garish. My second beef is sort of funny, but I would have really liked landing gear that completely closed up inside the ship, without the open spaces (same for the missile bays). I know that is something Hasbro does not do on very many ships, but it would have been a nice touch on the Y-wing. Thirdly, the turret. I like its shape and the controls for it, but that piece should have at least had elevating guns and been able to rotate.
All in all, I do like the new Y-Wing and am glad Hasbro made it, but it could have been a real gem.