Wow, revisiting the love of the POTF2 ship...
I have 2 that I'd label as "good". One that I'd label great for what it is actually.
I'm a ship nut by the way, and that's my focus in customizing right now while I perfect my casting technique and ability...
My 2 choices are the A-Wing and the T-16 Skyhopper...
The A-Wing is great because for a 1985 sculpt the thing holds it's own against even the TIE Bomber of today... It's deco is accurate to a film prop (Almost 100% accurate actually) and the pilot pack-in wasn't great, but there's worse. It's based on the maquette pilot instead of the actual actor's costume from Home One or cockpit shots, so I'm still itchin' for a new and accurate pilot on the card some day.
The best thing of the A-Wing though is that it's actually a TO SCALE ship... Not only that, it's a to-scale ship made from a vintage mold. You REALLY don't see that ever these days, so it's a welcome vehicle to me and that's why I welcome the Saga EU deco.
The T-16 I nominate because it's scale is arguably accurate (There's 2 proposed "sizes" from ILM, and the toy fits one of the 2). It's a new sculpt, fairly simple, VERY accurate to Luke's model he's seen playing with, and other than the cockpit interior I think it's pretty spot-on... I even like the cockpit interior a lot, just it could be better.
Other vehicles in the POTF2 range disappoint me because of their retread feel and they weren't improved much... Vader's TIE would get an honorable mention though as a great new vehicle from the POTF2 range.