Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Jesse James

Pages: 1 ... 1180 1181 1182 1183 1184 [1185] 1186 1187 1188 1189 1190 ... 1530
17761
Star Wars Universe / Re: Clone Wars = Canon or EU?
« on: March 27, 2006, 11:31 PM »
As Brad said, you pick and choose and that's what makes SW great and Star Trek, well, not as great I guess.  :)  Or so I've heard.

Anyway...  Lucas, as per my understanding, let the Clone Wars introduce Grievous but they inaccurately represented Grievous because Lucas allowed that and thus Grievous is "different" in the Cartoon...  That alone negates the Canon argument for Clone Wars to me, but the point still stands that what isn't in the film isn't considered Canon anyway by Lucas and Lucasfilm...  Part of the "official continuity" though?  Now that's another story, but that's where things go from being debatable to not really being debateable...  If that makes sense. 

In the grand scheme of things one can deny any of it...  But the films give people who want to seriously talk Star Wars shop like it's "real", some kind of basis or home with which to reference...  The EU just expands that (obviously) and is then open to debate...  The films are open to their own interpretations even.  For instance the actual length of a Super Star Destroyer is highly suspect by source material on the ship, yet the films give a canon answer...  One can still argue it.  Same with Fett's Death...  Did Fett die?  Didn't he?  Nobody so a body, things can be debated based on that...  The pure Canon is he died, EU says otherwise though so if you wanna talk Fett post ROTJ then you must accept he's alive yet.

With Clone Wars, it's my understanding Lucas only allowed them to do the lead-in and that it wasn't to make it canon but to throw them a bone and build hype...  They were given so much knowledge and to build from there, and they did, and I think it's great.  Clone Wars were awesome cartoons to watch.  I almost anticipated every new episode of those as much as a new film.  It was sorta sad.  I had to be home plopped in front of a TV, haha.

An interesting EU to Canon thing is Coruscant...  Lucas didn't want Coruscant as the name of the Galactic Capital when developing the prequals but Zahn had come up with it already...  It took convincing from LFL people to GET Lucas to accept it...  Begrudgingly I guess.  Coruscant is now "canon", but even Lucas wanted something else and he just went with it for his company's sake I guess.

This does bring up how the fat man in flannel will handle the TV shows though.  If Lucas makes them, do they become Canon?  They'd be like movies really...  Not that Indiana Jones has the following to ask, but I wonder what IJ fans think of the Young Indie Chronicles since Lucas made those...  Are they Indy Canon? :)

17762
See now, to me SOTE is a weaker effort than the Zahn trilogy...  I felt that anything that implied in it what it did (I'm trying not to spoil it for you) was a really bad way to take the story...  I didn't care for that.

That said I thought some of the new characters were interesting, I thought it did fill a gap...  I was mostly irritated with only a single aspect of the story rather than anything overall. 

I found SOTE to be mediocre...  OK, not something you felt ripped off after you read it, but ok...

Some stuff I found good reads...

-X-Wing (Comics & Novels)...  There's a number of these, they're good reads...  If you're really military oriented though may I suggest picking up the strategy guide to the original X-Wing and TIE Fighter PC games.  The guides are also the stories of the main pilot characters in both books (The "Farlander Papers" and "Steele Chronicles" are the actual names of the stories).  They're sort of their own thing, set aside from the X-Wing Rogue Squad books/comics but worth picking up with those IMO.  Hell, play the games, they're part of the story too. :)  The TIE Fighter story is interesting in particular because it integrates the story of Thrawn and how he goes from Vice Admiral in the Imperial Fleet to Grand Admiral...  You'll like it I think, though he's not a "main" character in the story.  It expounds a little on the "Secret Order" of assassins, and such that work under the Emperor's PERSONAL guidance...  Force adepts are more abundant in the galaxy than you might think, and Mara  isn't the only instrument the Emperor weilds...  I'll leave it at that. ;)

-Kyle Katarn's Story...  Kinda like the above with the games, Katarn's got 3 books dedicated to him and of course his games (Dark Forces and Jedi Knight being the integral parts of his story with 2 latter games and the add-on Mysteries of the Sith also adding to it but later in his life).  The Katarn story is, in my opinion, one of the best EU stories in all of Star Wars.  The story in the games is superior to the books, but you'll have that sometimes.  They're short reads though, very small, so they're worth it.

-Star Wars: Empire...  It's a recent, and still going, comic series.  I buy them when they put them all in one volume (trade paperback?  Graphic Novel?  Whatever they call them), and I found them highly enjoyable.  The one where the Empire are fighting the Amanin (Amanaman's species) is great...  It's like the Michael Caine movie about Rourke's Drift...  Very cool story, and really the whole Empire series is interesting to me.

-Star Wars: Tales...  This was just cancelled I guess but it was great while it was alive.  The comic series was neat because it was a number of short stories in one issue.  I got into it later so there's a lot I didn't read.  I need to buy these when they're all bound in one book or a number of "volumes" like Empire gets.  There were some ****** stories but some were pretty fantastic too.

-Republic Commando...  I haven't read the latest book, and to be honest I haven't read the first book, but I hear nothing but praise for the first with some mixed reviews on the second.  I highly suggest picking up Republic Commando though as it's on my to-read list.

-Tales of _______...  The "Tales of" series (Cantina, Jabba's Palace) is considered pretty good.  It has some flawed stories in it in my opinion.  With some weak attempts to ALWAYS tie main characters and things to basically "nothing", I think it exemplifies some negatives to EU IMO...  At the same time there's some cooler elements worth reading.  Most I know have picked these up.

-New Jedi Order...  It's a big series, and honestly I'm not a huge fan of it but I know others are.  It'd be irresponsible of me to say skip it then.  It's about the only way to read up on what happens to the Solo's and Skywalkers.  Other characters sneak into it too including (drum roll) Kyle Katarn and Keyan Farlander from 2 of the video games I mentioned...  Bit parts though as I understand it.

NJO is filled with some positives (IE: The NJO itself and how Skywalker reforms the Jedi Knights and Academy), and some not-so-positives (IE: Killing Chewbacca as a selling point rather than plot, other random killings to sell books, The Vong which I view as Star Trek rip-offs, etc.).  It's a popular series though so I think it's worth looking into...

I do NOT recommend Splinter of the Mind's Eye, Truce At Bakura, or Courtship...  I've read all 3, all 3 were disappointing to me in many ways.  Also I'd highly suggest not reading Dark Empire II...  Dark Empire I is eh...  Dark Empire II was corny and cheap.

I'm pretty picky though...  I like a lot of EU but for every good bit I enjoy there's probably 5 things I can't stand.  EU has an uncanny knack for trying to tie the main characters to every passer-by seen in the films or made up in books.  It's annoying really...  Add to that dumb stuff like the "Bantha Bar & Grill", or keeping EVERY character alive despite their assumed deaths in the films, and you can get into some annoyi8ng crap.

With that said...  The Boba Fett comics of the 90's aren't bad reads...  To be honest I even have been converted from a guy who HATED the idea of Fett "surviving" the Sarlaac to now actually digging that the Mandalorian one didn't necessarilly die...  if you like EU that is. ;)  Lucas says he died...  Armies of Fett Fanboys say otherwise, so that's the great hting about EU.  YOu can pick and choose what to believe.

I used to hate the notion and now I kind of dig seeing Fett resurface...  As old as he must be at that point, haha.  At some point the guy's gotta hang up the gauntlets though you figure. ;)

17763
Saga Collection '06 / Re: Army Building or Hoarding?
« on: March 27, 2006, 07:40 PM »
I wish all those things tied to army building were "good" though.  ;D

$15 Clone repaints, overpriced individual EE packs and the like are a plague...  In all honesty I look at the EE packs as something focused on the collecting mentality overall at first...  The intent that they get to army builders was negated by the packaging and price.  I see very few large SA Clone Wars Clone armies as a result...  Lower the price on individual sets, like the CT Stormtrooper and Sandtrooper sets were priced, and that's good army building IMO... 

I wish I'd been able to buy up the CW Clone sets at a good price but I had to settle...  A big bummer.   :-\

17764
Saga Collection '06 / Re: Army Building or Hoarding?
« on: March 27, 2006, 12:48 AM »
Guys, let's keep calm heads in this thread...

First, I have to agree with some of the posters Fritz that either what you said was being taken out of the context you intended it, or you were being a little rude with your wording...

"Lazy" and all that?  I think that's harsh.  I army build, I earn what I obtain too, but at the same time I think people need to keep the frame of mind that collecting isn't a "me me me" hobby if you're involved in communities like here at JediDefender or elsewhere too...  You should try, if possible, to look out for your friends in the hobby and not have the attitude that "You can have the scraps I leave you".  I mean, don't you think the way you worded that comes off a tad bit snobbish at best?  Even if it wasn't directed at anyone in this thread, which as mod here I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt there...

If it was pointed at anyone here, I really don't want to see that in the future.  I didn't agree with the original posters points about army builders...  To me, 95 figures is your right if you find them fair and square, and if you're a part of collecting and not scalping you're a welcome member of the collecting community. 

At the same time, I'd like to think most of the guys around these boards would've found 95 figures and shared some of them with local friends or friends online, whatever... 

Anyway, as noted I'm giving the benefit of the doubt with exactly how Fritzkrieg said what he did...  I don't think anyone in this thread has said they hate army builders or what they do...  Loathe the guy that posted the picture of 95 at Rebelscum perhaps, but not hating anyone IN THIS THREAD, and I don't think Fritzkrieg then was directing his hostility towards anyone.

At the same time I'm asking that we rethink what we're typing sometimes before we hit the "Post" button too...  It's easy to be in the targeted group.  When people can't find one, it's not always because they're lazy or whatnot...  I know that despite my best efforts around here I can't find much of anything nor can my local friends, so that's not laziness on our part, it's simply that this area doesn't have as much right now.  Hell our WM stores dont' even have pegs for figures, so that's a whole outlet gone from Pittsburgh right now...  Hardly lazy then.

And also, I'm an army builder, I build HUGE armies into the hundreds too...  To me it's part of what makes me happy, but at the same time I like to try to help at least a couple people out if I can...  Sometimes I give up something I really would rather keep, sometimes I keep everything I have (I've never sold a VOTC Stormie for instance), but at the end of the day I do like to pay the hobby back and I think everyone should try to do that some too...  Help a friend, help a stranger, whatever, but helping out someone to get ONE of something you have 250+ of isn't necessarilly a bad concept.

And definitely, please, don't gloat when it's obviously bothersome...  It's looking for trouble really.  That's what the guy at Rebelscum did and the point of the thread (to me) more than anything.  He posted the picture as a big middle finger to a LOT of people who aren't having an easy time in the hobby.  That's just not cool beans.  Thoughtfulness is cool and all that crap. :)

17765
Saga Collection '06 / Re: Army Building or Hoarding?
« on: March 25, 2006, 03:28 AM »
I say again though guys...  If you want this to change, the guy with 90 isn't the problem...  Hasbro and Retail are.  Till Hasbro packs a case of 4 UClones, 4 Scorch, and 4 Cody, those 3 figures are going to suck to find...

I don't know about all your areas, but I can speak for Pittsburgh.  In my area, out of at least 5 WM's I've hit lately, only 2 have pegs for figures and not one figure on them.  My Target stores have 3 or 4 pegs, and they're only ever sparsely filled with pegwarmers...  Very few "good" finds at these stores.

I can't find Utie Clones either, trust me, and not for lack of effort...  While I know some army builders are getting them around me, and I know some scalpers are too (saw them at the show a couple weeks ago), I also know Hasbro and retail are MAKING this hobby this way.  Look at the UGH ****...  The line is in its most dismal place if you ask me.  Hasbro I blame mostly...  Retail is still a close 2nd place.

It's ugly out there...  Our area just haven't gotten the large quantities out west seem to have picked up.  I have no clue why things are this bad...  I don't even think it's that the line is selling as well as last year, but rather that there's just nothing out there and I think there's a perception from many that crap is underproduced this year.  I dunno though, it's ugly at the stores though and I wish you could buy what you want when you want online without dealing with these stores at this point.

17766
Saga Collection '06 / Re: 2006 SDCC Exclusive Shadow Stormtrooper
« on: March 25, 2006, 03:18 AM »
I'm not sure on differences Paul...  I know that Carnor Jax's Stormtroopers are who are pictured on the reference images though and not the Marvel Black Hole Stormtroopers.

Personally, one in the same as far as my EU catalogue goes. :)

I'm hoping for 4...  4-man team is my standard for these overpriced figures these days.

17767
Toy Reviews / Re: New JD Review: AT-AT Driver
« on: March 25, 2006, 02:48 AM »
I have 4 At-AT Drivers...  Not a lot, but then again WM isn't carrying anything basic right now and Target is fluctuating its prices which is turning me off to army building.  I got some before every store out here jacked up prices again.

It's always something.

It's a great figure though.  It's everything the OTC TIE Pilot should've been actually, as his arms are weakly articulated and ironically the AT-AT Driver has quite nice articulation there.  Go figure huh?

17768
Customizing Tips and Tricks / Re: Fodder Alert!
« on: March 24, 2006, 04:38 AM »
There's pretty strong collecting market for those figures...  Plus those companies actually listen to, talk to, and deal with their consumer base and EMBRACE etailers...  Tack that onto them having limited brick & mortar retail support (Target doesn't carry them, TRU carries BBI but dumped 21st because of pressure from special interest groups and WM carries 21st but not BBI, and you have limited outlets to pick stuff up really).

Around me, they're backing up with certain things...  Battle of the Bulge never showed here heavily so I had a tough time tracking much down and never got all I wanted.  They repainted the Germans too and I only got one of them. :(  Never got the grey tankers or the Autumn Tankers.  I'm bummed.

Now my area's backing up with a wave I forgot plus the Japanese Infantry...  They repainted the Paratroopers and re-arranged the headsculpts to make Operation Market Garden U.S. Paratroopers.  It's a lesser-known part of World War two but if you wanna see a great movie about it watch "A Bridge Too Far".  Star-studded, well acted, historically accurate in many ways, and tells the sad facts of a sad story really.

Anyway, those and the Japanese are backing up here on top of the USMC figures which we got in droves.

I WISH I could find Battle of the Bulge.  It's my favorite battle and general piece of the war, and the figures are the best in my opinion.  I'd say the BotB line's best are as good as Hasbro's best basic figures like SA Clones... 

They're awesome fodder, but if you wind up with left-over parts of 21st C. figures because you only wanted the head or whatnot, PM ME HERE! :)  I can use those parts for my actual 1:18 military habit.  ;)

17769
Revenge of the Sith / Re: Revenge of the Sith - The Jedi
« on: March 24, 2006, 04:29 AM »
The irony of the ROTS Jedi was that they actually made me appreciate my AOTC Jedi more...

I felt dismal in 2002 when all figures were basically little PVC one-pose-wonders.  The extreme poses and expressions just ruined the line for me while they were the standard.  I don't know who thought that was the route to go, but if people wanted statues they'd not be buying action figures.  The line in 2002 suffered too and Star Wars had dismal sales compared to projections.  It was counted on to carry Hasbro in movie years and when it becomes a burden with buy-backs and whatnot, then there's a problem.

Flash forward to 2005 and I ironically now appreciate what I got in 2002 (for the most part anyway, not all of them got an update unfortunately), since now I have a great Shaak, Luminara, Aayla, Ki-Adi, etc...

The figures were outstanding last year for the most part.  Some duds leaked out, mostly towards the latter waves (Captain Antilles for instance), but figures like Ki-Adi Mundi are among my favorites in the modern line and will remain so.  Agen Kolar is practically perfect...  The girls had some limited bits here and there (Shaak's one arm is static for instance) but she's still neutral enough and pretty heavily articulated.

I don't think there's a Jedi figure save for the main ones that disappointed me.  That said, Mace Windu, the early Obi's, and Ani's were a letdown.  This line longs for a SA Mace Windu, seriously. 

If the Evolutions series had continued I wanted a Jedi assortment that included Mace as the Master, QGJ as the Jedi Knight, and an E1 Obi-Wan as the Padawan or some similar arrangement...  Mace deserves SA with one of the sweet Evolutions Anakin Robes.

For that matter, we still don't have a single decent prequal Yoda for all seasons.  The one they're re-releasing in the Heroes/Villains Wave is ok but the robe blows.  Put a cloth robe on that Yoda, throw in a cane...  I'm nearly happy with it.  I for some reason just enjoy that figure aside from the horrible robe.

17770
I'mg onna wager no on that Paul but the idea is the most logical.

Who here wouldn't be racing theirs with friends?  I want to make a Death Star obstacle course for astromechs.  :)  That'd be the ultimate toy to accompany these if you ask me...  lots of ramps, working elevators, tight turns, narrow walkways and such.

The RC-D2's are probably the best gimmick ever in the line...

17771
Saga Collection '06 / Re: Battle of Endor Wave
« on: March 24, 2006, 04:17 AM »
Paul, I was hoping for a new Endor Rebel too.  Sorely needed (as are all SA Rebel figures really), and I had hope...  I didn't have a LOT of hope though and I figured it was inevitably going to be a Saga or POTF2 trooper repainted.  I don't even think we'd have gotten a kitbash out of them on that one.

17772
Saga Collection '06 / Re: Army Building or Hoarding?
« on: March 24, 2006, 04:16 AM »
I haven't read everything in detail here but I'll give my thoughts...

First, army building isn't hoarding...  If you wanna hate someone, hate Hasbro and retail because they're making figures hard to find, not collectors.  Army builders are collectors, nothing more and nothing less.  They buy lots of figures NOBODY gave a **** about and helped you in your collecting life, I guarantee that.  Same with customizers...  They buy up the **** you don't care about and keep the pipes clean, or at least contribute to doing so.

That said...

The guy posted the picture to piss people off IMO, and I don't know how he got them but if it was via unscrupulous means then he's not someone I respect in the slightest.  I coulda gotten a figure at Target free the other day because she just scanned it once but I told her there were two there and she scanned the 2nd.  That's my morality kicking in and while I despise retailers I know stealing is wrong and that outweighs my hate.

Fact is, the guy has them opened so I'm inclined to think he wants them...  Of course, does a loose Utapau Clone sell for any less than a carded one?  I doubt it, so let me see this guy take a new picture of ALL these Cloens 10 years from now, and then I'll believe HE wanted them for himself...  I could easily see him breaking them up into groups and ebaying them to be a twit.  I don't know the guy, don't care either.

I firmly believe the photo was meant to irritate...  Personally I wouldn't post pictures of anything currently shipping to "show off" how many I have while others have none.  Do I want that many Utapau Clones?  You're damn right I do and if I could find (and afford) them you better believe I'd have 90 Utapau Clones all lined up like that too.   Don't hate me because I army build, hate Hasbro and Retail...

If that were even a dedicated army building thread like the "How many ____ do you have?" threads, I'd maybe not feel like this, but the guy started his own thread for that picture if I'm not mistaken, and that's just a middle finger to everyone...  Hell, if I had 90 Utapau Clones right now I'd probably dole out a set number to people on the boards.  One-per to everyone...  I'm sure I'd keep a certain ammount for me and my own collecting happiness but I know if I had 90 I'd be sharing with people a CERTAIN number of them.

Unfortunately, I'm struggling to just get to a number I'm content with...  I've yet to see a UTrooper in stores.  I've gotten mind from incredibly helpful friends.  I still don't even have a "team" though.  Paul knows what I'm saying. :)

17773
Watto's Junk Yard / Re: When you think of Canada....
« on: March 24, 2006, 03:28 AM »
Flapping heads full of lies and Terrance & Phillip


The ACTUAL great one.


And Niagara Falls actually having an attractive/good side to visit...

Oh and on a semi-serious note I think of the French & Indian War...  Used to re-enact for it, met a lot of Frenchies and Indians from up in the great white North who re-enacted too...  Always more fun than the brits my Scottish regiment dealt with. :)

17774
Toy Reviews / New JD Review: AT-AT Driver
« on: March 24, 2006, 02:25 AM »


This week's review is, as you can see, the Imperial AT-AT Driver resculpt from the "Hoth Wave".  Clicky the image above for the full review and enjoy!

My brief thoughts...  There's a lot to love with this figure and very little not to.  In 2006 we've seen a severely cut-back level of articulation across the board.  Fewer figures are near super poseable this year than we got in 2005's Revenge of the Sith line.  I for one was quite disappointed seeing that most figure's lacked knee arituclation, including some pretty great potential army builder fodder like Major Derlin and General Veers...  Hell, Bail Organa gets it in 2005 and Derlin and Veers get shorted in 2006?  bull****!

So that brings us to the AT-AT Driver...  The sculpting's fantastic and shows again that what you were happy with from the POTF2 line maybe wasn't as cool as you thought.  The great thing to me though is that, while the TIE Pilot resculpt really put its predecessor to shame, I find that the AT-AT Driver's resculpt blends in better with the POTF2 release figure.  That's a great thing to me though.

The figure comes packed with articulation though, and that is where it truly shines.  Ball/socket knees and shoulders, angle-cut elbow joints, wrists, neck, and waist make for a great poseable army builder.

If Hasbro made the AT-AT Driver's articulation the basic line's MINIMUM standard you'd read a hell of a lot more positive reviews out of me.  The 2004/05 POTC Cantina Wave had that articulation (more or less), and they're great...  Hasbro can make this a standard and if people would voice that they want it enough they'd cave and put out the effort we deserve.

Enjoy your AT-AT Driver people!  He's great, and unfortunately he's not the norm for quality this year, so don't expect too many to rival him for greatness.  Sad, but true.  You'll still get figure's with legs no more articulated than the Han Trenchcoat you bought in 1983...  Sucks ass when you think about it in those terms if you ask me.

17775
That is a pretty spiffy upgrade to the Jango helmet...  Helpful for multiple heads it can now fit.  I like the technique you used man, pretty seamless, as per usual with your work.  Very nice man, thanks for sharing it.

Pages: 1 ... 1180 1181 1182 1183 1184 [1185] 1186 1187 1188 1189 1190 ... 1530