Just breaking it out by position here
QB
2. DUSTRHO Destruction (dustrho) - Donovan McNabb, QB
4. The Famine (Famine) - Jesse Palmer, QB
8. The Zods (KBZ) - Peyton Manning, QB
12. Old Cocky Bastards (OCB) - Daunte Culpepper, QB
14. Nataku Dragons (Nataku) - Michael Vick, QB
18. purple cobras (jokafobe) - Brett Favre, QB
22. ThatOneTeam (Holo Elvis) - Matt Hassleback, QB
24. Nerfherders (mosnab) - Tom Brady, QB
25. The Famine (Famine) - Kurt Warner, QB
26. Canuckleheads (Morgbug) - Steve McNair, QB
28. Tatooine Express (reconsgt) - Trent Green, QB
29. Tatooine Express (reconsgt) - Aaron Brooks, QB
32. The Famine (Famine) - Eli Manning, QB
37. Nicklabs Nuckleheads (nicklab) - Marc Bulger, QB
38. Defending Champs (chuckles) - Chad Pennington, QB
RB
1. Tatooine Express (reconsgt) - Priest Holmes, RB
3. Canuckleheads (Morgbug) - Ladainian Tomlinson, RB
5. Nerfherders (mosnab) - Ahman Green, RB
6. Dressel's Rebellion (Dressel) - Shaun Alexander, RB
7. ThatOneTeam (Holo Elvis) - Clinton Portis, RB
10. Defending Champs (chuckles) - Deuce McAllister, RB
11. purple cobras (jokafobe) - Jamal Lewis, RB
13. Springfield Isotopes (Matt Carroll) - Edgerrin James, RB
17. Old Cocky Bastards (OCB) - Fred Taylor, RB
20. Nicklabs Nuckleheads (nicklab) - Marshall Faulk, RB
27. DUSTRHO Destruction (dustrho) - Rudi Johnson, RB
34. Dressel's Rebellion (Dressel) - Cory Dillon, RB
35. ThatOneTeam (Holo Elvis) - Stephen Davis, RB
36. The Zods (KBZ) - Domanick Davis, RB
40. Old Cocky Bastards (OCB) - Kevan Barlow, RB
42. Nataku Dragons (Nataku) - Michael Bennett, RB
43. Nataku Dragons (Nataku) - Brian Westbrook, RB
49. The Zods (KBZ) - Travis Henry, RB
52. Nerfherders (mosnab) - Kevin Jones, RB
53. The Famine (Famine) - Tiki Barber, RB
WR
9. Nicklabs Nuckleheads (nicklab) - Randy Moss, WR
15. Nataku Dragons (Nataku) - Marvin Harrison, WR
19. Defending Champs (chuckles) - Torry Holt, WR
21. The Zods (KBZ) - Terrel Owens, WR
23. Dressel's Rebellion (Dressel) - Hines Ward, WR
33. Nerfherders (mosnab) - Darrell Jackson, WR
39. purple cobras (jokafobe) - Chad Johnson - WR
41. Springfield Isotopes (Matt Carroll) - Santana Moss, WR
45. Old Cocky Bastards (OCB) - Derrick Mason, WR
46. purple cobras (jokafobe) - Joe Horn, WR
47. Defending Champs (chuckles) - Steve Smith, WR
50. ThatOneTeam (Holo Elvis) - Laveranues Coles, WR
51. Dressel's Rebellion (Dressel) - Andre Johnson, WR
54. Canuckleheads (Morgbug) - Javon Walker, WR
TE
16. Springfield Isotopes (Matt Carroll) - Tony Gonzalez, TE
30. DUSTRHO Destruction (dustrho) - Kellen Winslow, TE
31. Canuckleheads (Morgbug) - Alge Crumpler, TE
48. Nicklabs Nuckleheads (nicklab) - Todd Heap, TE
Defense
44. Springfield Isotopes (Matt Carroll) - Ravens DEF