Got back from vacation today and promptly went out and found these at the Hot Topic near my house. Luckily they had 3 of each set, so I was able to pick the ones with the best paint apps. They are definitely pretty hit or miss. I'm happy with the ones I got, but would have had to pass if those hadn't been there. One of the sets had a Demogorgon leg just floating around which must have come loose during shipping. The others had the wonky eyes like from your pic, Rob.
They also had a BOGO 30% off deal, so I saved about $6 which was nice.