haha, I actually love the look of that.
it's worked its way into multiple games as an Imperial Standard almost, so I kinda dig that... It's campy but it gives a strange "real" quality to the movie in a small way.
I'd say the space battles, both ANH's and ROTJ's, need major CGI overhauls... You could do 10x as much with each. The lil CGI snip-its in ANH were improvements, but honestly I think the models should've been deleted out for CGI ships. The explosions are noticeably pants for everything but the TIE's shot down in CGI.
ROTJ's still got noticeable frames in the space scenes too that need fixed if nothing else, but could you imagine some CGI broadsiding between Imperial and Rebel capital ships, or the sight of a Rebel Corvette aflame taking a last-ditch ram into the command tower of a Destroyer?
What about a fighter increase too?
It's the best space battle, but for a climactic battle it could use some expansion I think, and shows the age of the films a bit more than anything to me, especially the battle in ANH.