Its kind of exciting to make one of these lists when there is basically a clean slate of wide open selections, like the early POTF2 days or something. There are a lot of characters that seem like they'd be slam dunks, but I guess I'll make my list like we've got one more year of this or something. I'm all in for doing all of the vintage (original) line figures as well, and it looks like the lists so far are heavily (almost completely) OT based.
1. Darth Vader
2. Chewbacca
3. C-3PO
4. Princess Leia - ANH
5. Luke Skywalker - Tatooine
6. Obi-Wan "Old Ben" Kenobi
7. Lando Calrissian - Bespin
8. Yoda
9. Bossk (and all bounty hunters)
10. Jabba the Hutt
It is tough to leave it at 10, since we're basically starting fresh. I want all the bounty hunters, all the Cantina aliens (particularly the "main" ones), troops, Hoth stuff, etc. Not to mention all the beasts and everything. Looking at it if we had one more year of these (although I'm sure we'll get more), I'd at least want to have the ANH lineup.