1. Bom Vimdin | 16. Emperor Palpatine (Senate Duel) |
2. Weequay (Skiff Master) | 17. Endor Rebel Soldier (Super Articulated Resculpt) |
3. Bespin Han Solo (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 18. Fozec |
4. Torryn Farr | 19. Kithaba |
5. Doctor Evazan (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 20. Lumat/Wompus |
6. Ponda Baba (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 21. Nien Nunb (Super Articulated Resculpt) |
7. Hoth Princess Leia (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 22. Nikto (Vintage version) |
8. Rebel Fleet Trooper (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 23. Sim Aloo |
9. ANH Grand Moff Tarkin (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 24. Zam Wessel (Super Articulated Resculpt) |
10. Hoth Rebel Soldier (Echo Base) | 25. Tonnika Sisters (2-Pack) |
11. Hoth Luke Skywalker (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 26. Joruus C'baoth |
12. Mosep | 27. Admiral Pellaeon |
13. Sergeant Doallyn | 28. Imperial Commander (SA Black Tunic) |
14. Admiral Ackbar (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 29. Guri |
15. Cliegg Lars | 30. ?? |
- 4-AD (Clone Wars 3D) | - Lt Sheckil |
- Ackmena | - Lumpawarrump |
- Anakin Skywalker (Clone Wars 3D Cold Weather) | - Magna Droid (Super Articulated Resculpt) |
- Anakin Skywalker (Outlander Super Articulated Resculpt) | - Mawhonic |
- Ann and Tann Gella | - Merumeru |
- Barriss Offee (Super Articulated Resculpt) | - Nute Gunray (Clone Wars 3D) |
- Bastila Shan | - Obi-Wan Kenobi (Clone Wars 3D Cold Weather) |
- Ben Quadrinaros | - Owen Lars (ANH Super Articulated Resculpt) |
- Bollux | - Padme (Post-Senate) |
- Captain Piett (Super Articulated Resculpt) | - Padme Amidala (Buns Hairdo) |
- Captain Rex (Clone Wars 3D Cold Weather) | - Padme Amidala (Funeral) |
- Cin Drallig | - Padme Amidala (Lake Retreat) |
- Dak Ralter (Super Articulated Resculpt) | - Padme Amidala (Outlander) |
- Darth Vader (Medical Capsule Super Articulated Resculpt) | - Padme Amidala (Packing) |
- Dash Rendar (Super Articulated Resculpt) | - Padme Amidala (Peacock) |
- Dorme | - Padme Amidala (Senator) |
- Emperor Palpatine (Office Duel Super Articulated Resculpt) | - PK Droid |
- Jan Ors | - R5-A7 |
- Jar Jar Binks (Super Articulated Resculpt) | - R5-X2 |
- Jocasta Nu | - Tey How |
- Kitster/Wald | - Thi-sen (Clone Wars 3D) |
- Leebo | - Wedge Antilles (Snowspeeder Super Articulated Resculpt) |
There are two rules - #1 you only get one vote per member and #2 your vote has to be one of the JD Wishlist: ToC nominees listed below. If you vote more than once or pick someone not on the list, your post(s) will be deleted!
Wait - did they make or announce Wooof and I missed it? Because that's what I want.
Bastila Shan.
I vote for Emperor Palpatine (senate duel), but you guys need to be more clear about which Palpatine you're specifying. On the full story for the front page article you listed Emp. Palpatine (office duel). This is him in red robes for the Mace +3 Jedi fight. The one I'm voting for is the dark gray robes for the duel vs. Yoda in the senate chamber. I wish they'd make both really.
Rebel Fleet TrooperRead the directions
Rebel Fleet TrooperRead the directions
My vote: JOCASTA NU
Question: Why are we accepting nominations for (Ackmena) and why do we have characters on our list (Tonnikas...) that have been put off limits by Hasbro for this poll... they stated at Comic Con that Toy Fair has been instructed to not even include these in the final poll... isn't this just wasting voting spots?
Off Limits:
Tonnika Sisters (either)
any character based on George Lucas himself.
Grebleips (the ET senators)
Tyvokka & Jedi Wookiees
any live-action character from the Holiday Special
My vote: JOCASTA NU
Question: Why are we accepting nominations for (Ackmena) and why do we have characters on our list (Tonnikas...) that have been put off limits by Hasbro for this poll... they stated at Comic Con that Toy Fair has been instructed to not even include these in the final poll... isn't this just wasting voting spots?
Off Limits:
Tonnika Sisters (either)
any character based on George Lucas himself.
Grebleips (the ET senators)
Tyvokka & Jedi Wookiees
any live-action character from the Holiday Special
Because they've been instructed by Lucas film that these are off limits. Any would be wasted slots.
With the Tonnika Sisters, Lucasfilm never got permission from the Actresses to use their likeness for toys (or something like that.)
The E.T.'s are owned by a different studio. Lucas had special permission to use them himself.
The Holiday Special - Lucas is trying to destroy all evidence of it's existence.
I can't say for sure about the other two, but there are reasons dictated by Lucas film.
I honestly think Ackmena has a shot, maybe a longer one but I think she may find her way into plastic. Now Chewies family on the other hand has no chance in hell. Ackmena is not a wasted slot in my opinion.
I honestly think Ackmena has a shot, maybe a longer one but I think she may find her way into plastic. Now Chewies family on the other hand has no chance in hell. Ackmena is not a wasted slot in my opinion.
I'd buy a Mallatobuck figure. He'll she'd be an easy repaint of any number of Chewbacca figures out there. Easy money for Hasbro.
Lumpy could be a nice pack in, or a two pack with another small figure.
And who wouldn't want an "Itchy" figure! LOL.
Seriously though, I'd buy a Chewbacca family set if it were made. Totally serious on that.
Question: Why are the Tonnikas still on the list since when announcing this Hasbro even stated they hope fans don't waste a vote for them since they won't make them? Similarly, in a recent Q&A they said they wouldn't make Ackmena. I mean, I'm all for voting for who you want, but I think Hasbro already knows we want them, but (for different reasons) neither Ackmena nor the Tonnikas will be made.
Question: Why are we accepting nominations for (Ackmena) and why do we have characters on our list (Tonnikas...) that have been put off limits by Hasbro for this poll... they stated at Comic Con that Toy Fair has been instructed to not even include these in the final poll... isn't this just wasting voting spots?
Off Limits:
Tonnika Sisters (either)
any character based on George Lucas himself.
Grebleips (the ET senators)
Tyvokka & Jedi Wookiees
any live-action character from the Holiday Special
I have not seen the official rules...so I am waiting for Jeff to answer that since he has them. I know they have said those figures were off limits in the past but its our list, you know what I mean. I know other sites specifically said that but it could be their own interpretation of what Hasbro has said in the past.
My vote goes toWhat a surprise! ::)
Jocasta Nu
My vote goes toWhat a surprise! ::)
Jocasta Nu
I'd say anyone with less than 50 posts ought not to be considered; whose vote is this supposed to be for, the real JD community or random people who will never return to the site again after that one post?
I have not seen the official rules...so I am waiting for Jeff to answer that since he has them.
whose vote is this supposed to be for, the real JD community or random people who will never return to the site again after that one post?
the random posters make this feel a bit fraudulent and not very collective of the site want
The "Thank you for being a friend" pack?
I'm just really bothered by their flat out EXCLUSION from this poll. Doesn't Jedi Defender pride itself on being above stuff like this?
I have to side with the newbies here. Why can't their votes be treated like everyone else's? Don't you guys want to encourage participation?
I don't think anyone is aiming to discourage new members from signing up and sticking around and contributing and enjoying themselves. At the same time, we'd rather that JD's top-30 reflect the wishes of the membership here, and not the membership of other sites. So there's a balance that needs to be struck.
And to those that are going to say "we'd like to impress upon Hasbro how much we want the Tonnika... yadda yadda"...Do you actually even read this thread? "We" already explained that
Do we really have waste a spot for this?
Why not just add a little intro paragraph to your poll list indicating how highly the Tonnikas scored, but that you pulled them from the list because of the rules...
...also Stan has confirmed casting for new mold
Who's Stan?
Voting will close at 11:59pm on August 21st! For housekeeping purposes, please post ONLY your votes in this thread. Please post all thoughts/comments on the poll in the regular JD Wishlists 2009: Discussion (http://www.jedidefender.com/yabbse/index.php?topic=18861.0) thread. Thanks!
Who's Stan?
And, as far as I recall, he's never been dead wrong.
1 vote for jocasta nu, please
C'mon Rob everyone knows S.T.A.N. (Spy To Alert Nerds)
Oh, what a surprise! Another new member who wants to vote for Jocasta... and who just happens to have the same IP address as one of the other new members who just happens to want Jocasta Nu! Shock! ::)
Are you sure your user ID wasn't supposed to be Arie45895 so it matches your other account?
and, it looks like Jocasta was tied to Owen's 8 with Scott's vote and is now at 11.
Uh oh, Hulk angry.
Uh oh, Hulk angry.
Hulk know how to read IP's... Grrrrrrrr.
In all honesty, this attitude makes me feel like... "why would I even want to join here? New members are obviously not welcome." Now you guys were here first - - I get that. But if you want new folks to come on board and make this site as big as Scum and other sites, why do you want to dissuade people from joining in? It just doesn't make sense to me.
Anyway... I just thought I'd mention this after reading all that before I got to the point.
Why are you even having the voting open at all? ::)
I'd say anyone with less than 50 posts ought not to be considered; whose vote is this supposed to be for, the real JD community or random people who will never return to the site again after that one post?
1. Bom Vimdin | 16. Emperor Palpatine (Senate Duel) |
2. Weequay (Skiff Master) | 17. Endor Rebel Soldier (Super Articulated Resculpt) |
3. Bespin Han Solo (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 18. Fozec |
4. Torryn Farr | 19. Kithaba |
5. Doctor Evazan (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 20. Lumat/Wompus |
6. Ponda Baba (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 21. Nien Nunb (Super Articulated Resculpt) |
7. Hoth Princess Leia (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 22. Nikto (Vintage version) |
8. Rebel Fleet Trooper (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 23. Sim Aloo |
9. ANH Grand Moff Tarkin (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 24. Zam Wessel (Super Articulated Resculpt) |
10. Hoth Rebel Soldier (Echo Base) | 25. Tonnika Sisters (2-Pack) |
11. Hoth Luke Skywalker (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 26. Joruus C'baoth |
12. Mosep | 27. Admiral Pellaeon |
13. Sergeant Doallyn | 28. Imperial Commander (SA Black Tunic) |
14. Admiral Ackbar (Super Articulated Resculpt) | 29. Guri |
15. Cliegg Lars | 30. Bastila Shan |