Newsarama's results are in, and Mark Valley was the voters' choice. I wonder if he will get any actual consideration for the role. He is a little older (44), but I guess RDJ was 42 when he filmed Iron Man - and as was mention in Newsarama's article, it would be strange to see a 42 year old RDJ and a 20-25 actor playing Cap in an Avengers movie. We'll see I guess.
Fillion finished 2nd. I really enjoy him as an actor, but like many others, I always pictured him more as Hal Jordan - a role I hope he's considered for when it comes up. Anyways, hopefully Marvel will announce their choice pretty soon as they now have a director, writers, and release date for Cap.