27
« on: August 8, 2017, 08:42 AM »
This post is coming from someone who's read the books, followed up on the R+L=J theory to fully understand it, as well as read multiple forums on other's opinions and thoughts, so there's information below that the show didn't fully touch upon. If you're thinking about reading the books and don't want to be spoiled, you've been warned.
Jon is 100% Rhaegar and Lyanna's son. There's no secret R or L to the equation. Lyanna and Robert were supposed to be married and Robert was all for it as he truly loved Lyanna. Lyanna wanted nothing to do with it as she knew Robert was a womanizing drunk who would still cheat on her if given the opportunity (and he would have plenty). Why would Lyanna let Robert dip his wick, produce a son and then tell Ned to lie about it? It doesn't make any sense.
As to who is the rightful heir, I'm in the opinion that it's Jon. Rhaegar and Lyanna were gone for almost a year before R rode off to fight against the rebellion and ultimately be slain by Robert. Targaryens were known to take multiple wives (Aegon the First had two and they started the line when they invaded Westeros). During that year, I'm of the opinion that R&L secretly got married and produced Jon. There are hints in the books that point to Jon being a legitimate heir (all assuming R&L were married, of course):
1. The Kingsguard at the Tower of Joy. Why would three Kingsguard, including the Lord Commander and possibly the greatest swordsman in the realm in Sir Arthur Dayne be posted there if not to protect royalty? Remember at this point, Rhaegar had already left to fight in the battles and was known to have died. Why didn't they go with him initially or why weren't they with Aerys' wife, Viserys and the soon to be born Dany after he died? At this point, everyone knew it was a real possibility Robert had a chance to win and Aerys could die, so the next in line to the throne would be Viserys, the second born son. Kingsguard weren't with those three and three Kingsguard wouldn't be left at the ToJ to protect some bastard and the prince's side piece whore. They were there to protect Jon as the legitimate heir to Prince Rhaegar.
2. Everyone's thoughts and feelings about Rhaegar (not including Robert as his opinion was skewed because he thought Lyanna was constantly being raped). Everyone, from Ned to Sir Barristan to Cersei to the common folk had nothing but nice things to say about Rhaegar. He doesn't seem like the type of person to keep a girl as a side piece to use as he pleased. I believe he truly loved Lyanna, she him and they were married.