Finished up opening my basic figures yesterday, and overall I'm pretty impressed with this line. No real terrible figures as far as what I have, and some are quite well done. I'm particularly impressed with the "background" Jedi figures, pretty much all of the Jedi outside of Anakin, Obi, and Mace. Those figures are all very well done I think, and worlds better than their AOTC counterparts. Although the Anakin, Obi, and Mace figures aren't awful, I really wish we could see them done in the same manner as the rest of these Jedi. Mace is probably one of the better ones we've seen, but for some reason I'm having trouble getting past those shoulders.
I also like the Clonetroopers, even with the action feature. I can't wait to see what the superposeable version is like in person, and hopefully not nearly as tough to find as the Clone Wars version. Other favorites:
Chewie and Tarfful - Always fan of the wookiees, but was a bit concerned about them after some of the pics online. Blonde highlights seem to be slightly overdone, but the Chewie I got actually looks pretty nice. Maybe I just got one with a toned down paintjob. Tarfful is good as well, although not quite as spiffy as I expected. I do like them both though.
C-3PO, Padme, Bail...well, pretty much all of Coll 2 - Great figures. Maybe one of the best 3POs we've gotten, if still under-articulated. Padme is one of the favorite Padme figures we've seen too. The face seems closer than most we've gotten. Bail is good for what he is, as can be said for the majority of Collection 2.
The Rest of Collection 1 - These figures to me are not too bad, but nothing spectacular. I do like the Emperor figure (loads better than the Saga version to me), and Vader is alright too (although VOTC is a bit better). Grievous and his bodyguards are pretty cool too. I didn't pick up R2 yet, since it seems that he isn't a big hit with those who have him...and from the poster it looks like we'll be getting another one down the road.
Overall, I really like this line. I think it is one of the better ones we've seen for awhile, particularly among the PT "movie" lines. To be honest, it really makes me realize how much crap we got during the AOTC craze. I kind of wish I wouldn't have gotten so much during that time, as so much of it pales in comparison to these and other figures we have gotten since then. Probably why much of it is packed away.