Considering that I have never, ever seen Shai Lebouf in ANYTHING AT ALL, I'll put my trust in Spielberg and Lucas. Speilbeg continues to make great, smart films, so I'll follow him anyhwre. While the prequels didn't live up to anyones expectations, the casting was excellent! Liam Neeson. Ewan McGregor. Christopher Lee. Even Hayden ended up being right for the part. Whining about this kid is just tired and childish. I think this movie will be great.