As far as the AL MVP goes, A-Rod and David Ortiz had equal numbers, except A-Rod is a gold glover with an average 20 points higher and David Ortiz is fat with a few more RBIs. Mark Teixeira has the same numbers too but his team sucked. Winner: A-Rod.
NL: eh, Pujols. Andruw Jones had 51 HRs and 128 RBIs, but hit .263. Derrek Lee had almost-Pujols numbers but his team sucked.
Yeah, so A-Rod and Pujols.