With how much influence and innuendo peddled by the RS presidential camp?
I never said Philip didn't help Dustin get elected. Rebelscum pimped Dustin every day like a 2 dollar hooker. I guess the big difference between me and the people complaining is I don't see how that's a crime. The site he's worked at for years backed his campaign. No big shocker there.
Where'd the rumors about USC come from? Smear campaign or truth?
As far as I saw, they came from people on various Star Wars forums who simply posted links directly to things USC wrote (and that he later admitted he wrote on those radio interviews). No conspiracy there, but I know when I read that stuff....I didn't particularly care much for the guy. I wondered after listening to him how he got so many people to vote for him. The only 2 explanations that seemed reasonable were he was buying votes himself, or people who were sick of the Dustin campaign were throwing votes his way.
All that bitching prior to the contest deadline about everything and suddenly the "good guys" win?
The fact that Philip and Dave bitched about Dustin not being ahead seemed like a brief bit of honesty from those guys. I've rarely seen the staff over there (save a few moderators) speak their minds blatantly like that, so when they bitched about Dustin being behind, I thought it was funny. Then again.....I also thought at that point it was lame, because they were preaching "this is all for fun" in one sentence and "This is crap" with the next.
Again...that's not conspiracy, that's just a few guys being up front about how they're pissed they're not winning. Scroll page to the first few pages of this thread. Lots of honesty there too.

Riiiiiiiiight. Got any bridges to sell Josh?
I don't see how I'm trying to sell anything. I'm simply saying I don't buy into the whole "Philip is the mastermind behind this whole thing" theory. If he somehow bent the will of StarWars.com and got them to reverse some public and obvious "election" results, then that guy has clout like I never knew about.
However, the whole "occams razor" thing says the easiest solution is probably the solution. I'd wager StarWarsShop DQ'd the other guy because of something he said, or something he did.
I'd love to know what that was.
But for the record, yes....if Dustin and Philip somehow blackmailed StarWars.com and Lucasfilm into reversing an election, and somehow that gets discovered.....I will join everyone in being completely floored.