I can definitely see the $50 pricepoint argument... for me, $'s everyone's own individual battle and it either works for you, or it doesn't. Perceived Value was a basic thing I had drilled into my head throughout school, and how it varies so greatly from person to person. I've cited it before, and gladly will again, that I've plunked some serious coin down for things I like like Acid Rain toys and stuff... I mean a LOT of $, and sometimes I haven't hesitated because what it is appeals to me so much. $30/figure (roughly, a lil less) is a tough pill to swallow and I usually buy in 3s now when I do my initial pre-ordering with EE.
Looking at these, I get it that $50 is absurd for some, and for me it kind of is too. I haven't 100% decided If I'd buy one, both, or none at full price. I think, if I do, I'll get the Vader one full price because I easily can see my Bandai Kit figures working with it too, but I could just as easily see myself waiting for sales/clearance because that price scares me a bit too. It doesn't really move, or have much "play" to it at all. It's really just a "glorified stand" (I should trademark that like Pawlus did "different enough to make you mad").
I like that it lights up and the effect appears to be well done. I like the detailing (screws/rivets detailed into the sculpt, etc.). And again I'd say compare this to that Lars Homestead and it's not all that different in terms of what you ultimately get with it. It's also not an "iconic" scene from any of the movies though, and more just some imaginary mega-stand.
At the same time, and this is more to the hypothetical debate, yes you could've would've should've gotten something cooler for 4" but you're not going to... not now anyway. But I get that POV too, Dave. I just am taking the thought that life handed me lemons, and I'm going to make some kind of 4" scaled Lemonade from it I guess. I can look at the ENTIRE 6" line that way (that it sucks and I want 4" scaled stuff) but that's not likely to change. Not this year anyway. Maybe not ever. So these are there, and these may work for me... in some capacity at least.
But again the Perceived Value argument, yeah, sure anything hits a price point low enough and it's easier to look past the hatred. And I'm there too. Right now I'm not sure if I'll need a discount to buy one of these or not though. I am still debating. But I could see at least the Vader one appealing to me.
Re: them coming off the base, from the looks of it in pictures they're separate pieces, at the very least. Whether they're intended to come off the base or not, I'm not sure, but I think they certainly CAN come off the base with persuasion.

I really can't say I'm arguing for you guys to buy them, or not, as I really hate 6" stuff too and all that. And I don't know what I'll pay for one of these either. I appreciate you guys reading it though, and giving some feedback and personal thoughts in return. It's a hell of a lot more fun than watching everyone just say they hate everything and F Hasbro and F the hobby and stuff. Why be here at all then, ya know? Gotta find fun somewhere, even if Hasbro's not looking at you as particularly important right now. I know they're not looking at me that way, at least.

I'm still finding fun though, every year.