At the risk of further ridicule....
I took a gander over at wizarduniverse and here are the figures that interest me right now:
Justice League Flash
Aquaman and Black Canary
The classic silver age stuff is really nice too, but far too pricey for me to get into it as a side line click me to look
I'd also probably pick up a Hal Jordan GL figure to round it out.
My DC days were about equal to my Marvel days early on. I've mentioned before when we got shuttled off to the cabin at the lake (Aunt and Uncle's place) on rainy days we'd read comics. I had my hands on a massively beaten copy of Amazing Fantasy 15 at the time too (cover gone, numerous ripped pages). It was later on that I really got more into Marvel in my late teens. But I got a ton of joy out of DC comics in the early years and those characters were some of my favorites (Catwoman included).