Oh they had other establishments in Indy that had liquor. My hangouts were mainly Hard Times Cafe and the Ram because of this.
Hard Times had a good, strong margarita called Halfway House. They also had some good chili- 4 different types- it was a hole in the wall place right next to the con by Houlihan's.
The Ram's regular mixed drinks, not too fond of. The martini's were ok. The beer was actually pretty good.
My favourite drink though: Jillian's Tea- it had around 5 different liquors w/ a Sprite base. It was the night I had 4 of these that you saw me outside of Rocky Bottoms.

Also, went to the Clauddaugh twice- wasn't too fond of it, and no cute guys in there- unless I brought them in!
As far as male hotties, Scott, if we were to make a list of JD guys- it would be long... at least my list...