136
The Prequel Trilogy / Re: Jedi = Star Trek red shirts?
« on: July 31, 2005, 07:44 AM »
heh, I've been calling the NJO "newbie" jedi Red Shirts for years!
They show up at the beginning of the book to be 'offed' at the end. At least the film ones, most stuck around for a couple of movies. Even in the books the jedi a pretty whimpy.
I was sorely disappointed by the simplicity of killing the Jedi in Revenge as well. And the Jedi they showed tended to be Council ones too. The cream of the crop and they just bought it like nothing. Kind of makes you wonder about the intelligence of Sidious.
I had been hoping that Sidious would have cloned more silent avengers (i.e. Mauls) for that fight. Imagine the spectacle of that!
They could have at least shown the jedi really taking down the clones with them, or perhaps having the Star Destroyers just bombarding them into nothing. I could see that working.
Lucas was totally lazy for the Sidious battle. You barely see a flash and all three council Jedi are toast. Then you get a little manuvering around with Mace and that's it. Sure you can pawn it off to saying Sidious was clouding their minds or no one knew Sith Lords were tough little buggers, but they all knew about Maul. That's a pretty tough yardstick there.
<b>Guys, the whole point of the Prequels is that the Jedi were arrogant and when their attackers came after them they were caught off guard.</b> Good point speeder! I could see them stopping and thinking "What's the from my clones? A threat?! huh? Ouch that hurts....gasp croak"
They show up at the beginning of the book to be 'offed' at the end. At least the film ones, most stuck around for a couple of movies. Even in the books the jedi a pretty whimpy.
I was sorely disappointed by the simplicity of killing the Jedi in Revenge as well. And the Jedi they showed tended to be Council ones too. The cream of the crop and they just bought it like nothing. Kind of makes you wonder about the intelligence of Sidious.
I had been hoping that Sidious would have cloned more silent avengers (i.e. Mauls) for that fight. Imagine the spectacle of that!
They could have at least shown the jedi really taking down the clones with them, or perhaps having the Star Destroyers just bombarding them into nothing. I could see that working.
Lucas was totally lazy for the Sidious battle. You barely see a flash and all three council Jedi are toast. Then you get a little manuvering around with Mace and that's it. Sure you can pawn it off to saying Sidious was clouding their minds or no one knew Sith Lords were tough little buggers, but they all knew about Maul. That's a pretty tough yardstick there.
<b>Guys, the whole point of the Prequels is that the Jedi were arrogant and when their attackers came after them they were caught off guard.</b> Good point speeder! I could see them stopping and thinking "What's the from my clones? A threat?! huh? Ouch that hurts....gasp croak"