Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - StBrianOfMinneapolis

Pages: 1 ... 8 9 10 11 12 [13] 14 15 16 17 18 ... 21
181
TV-9D9 / Re: Star Wars Resistance
« on: January 13, 2020, 02:51 PM »
That last ep on Empok Nor....the FO refueling station. The First Order is okay with Nikto as technicians?
I have no idea...who is supposed to be speciesist this week?

I did get a kick out of the technician suits. I was kind of hoping that was "Matt" sneaking around.

182
TV-9D9 / Re: The Mandalorian (SPOILERS possible)
« on: January 13, 2020, 02:44 PM »
The durability of Beskar seems like it's going to be an ongoing plot point.  What's going to happen with all of that armor that was left behind on Nevarro?  The Armorer no doubt will have some plans for that.  And having seen how much punishment Beskar can take in this first season, it makes one particular character's survival seem far more plausible.

BUT....

There's a character in the Aftermath series of canon novels who lives on Tatooine and has acquired a suit of Mandalorian armor.  That character's name is Cobb Vanth, and his story (if the timeline is accurate) takes place around 4 years after the Battle of Endor.  The novels didn't indicate with any certainty if Vanth's armor was the salvaged armor of Boba Fett.  This was one of a number of subplots in the Aftermath novels.  Whether or not it leads to anything linked to this series remains to be seen.  Given Dave Filoni's role in the show I can see the potential for him to explore some linkage between print media and the series.  From what I've read George Lucas stated that Boba Fett escaped from the Sarlacc, but declined to show that in the special edition.  So this might be an instance of Favreau and Filoni carrying the torch forward and exploring that angle.

Should we assume that all Mandalorian armor is Beskar? It seemed like only Din Djarin's helmet was Beskar in the first episode and he only got upgrades as he earned them. Maybe it's the case that true Mando armor is Beskar for only those who have arrived.

On a different note, I'm going to assume the ice cream maker full of beskar came from Gideon, possibly to lure out a Mando?

And on a final unrelated note, I'm guessing the "retcon" on the Mando way of life relates to ancient Mandalorians rather the the recent Clone Wars era of Satine and Deathwatch. The Way probably has much more to do with the era of the Darksaber. Maybe this ancient connection will somehow include Jango and Boba even thought some CW episode stated they were not Mandos.

183
TV-9D9 / Re: The Mandalorian (SPOILERS possible)
« on: January 10, 2020, 12:40 PM »
New thought...

Can Beskar steel repel the Darksaber? I'm not clear if the Darksaber had the same ability to cut throw almost everything.

184
Regarding a JJ cut... I have noticed coincidentally that all the dialogue in the movie is pretty tight in a good way. There's a lot of fast conversations with few lulls to slow things down. I've even wondered if they reshot some scenes just to produce off the tight dialogue as it feels like they started with a tight pace to begin with. That or they just got really lucky.

On an unrelated topic... I was originally not pleased to see another desert planet in the original trailer. However, I felt the time spent on Pasaana depicted such a different culture with the celebration and the pace so moved quickly that I was happy we weren't spending another 30-40% of a movie on yet another desert planet. In my five viewings I've never been reminded of Tatooine or Jakku. Pasaana just feels like Pasaana.


185
TV-9D9 / Re: The Mandalorian (SPOILERS possible)
« on: January 6, 2020, 10:42 AM »
The Incinerator Trooper was a great nod to The Force Unleashed.  And the fact that Gideon had his own squad of Death Troopers?  He's clearly got some status to merit an elite unit like that.

I agree that he probably has a Star Destroyer or some other capital ship(s) at his disposal.  Those troops probably weren't just hanging around on another part of Nevarro, because the bounty hunters guild would certainly have known about a garrison that size.

Based on what we saw in TROS?  Gideon might be in a league of officers much like General Pryde - officers who were closely allied with the Emporer, and seeking out Force sensitives at the direction of the Emporer himself.... even in the post ROTJ era.

I'll be intrigued to see how vast Gideon's resources are. Arriving in one single TIE makes him either a badass or a one-time Moff who is now scraping by.

186
I have heard there’s a lot extra footage out there and hope they are able to bundle it all someday.  I’d love to see things that got cut like the aforementioned forcey Finn stuff.  I don’t necessarily need it integrated or anything.  I just love cut footage.  I’m boggled at how much Jackson cut from the Hobbit films.

I'm boggled at how much Jackson put into the Hobbit films.

On another note, my wish was granted by the Resistance cartoon with an appearance of Sidon Ithano and his Meson Martinet. Now I have to find that ship in ROS.

187
TV-9D9 / Re: The Mandalorian (SPOILERS possible)
« on: January 5, 2020, 10:18 AM »
I figured Gideon has many many more stormtroopers than were there.  Just my guess anyway.

So, after watching this again the stormtrooper counts are really bugging me.  There's a slew of them in town with a vast amount of reinforcements when Gideon shows up.
[/q]
Yeah the amount of troopers that were finally revealed on the outside of the lava cave was bizarrely low.  IG could have dispatched all those without detonating himself so the story would have made a lot more sense if there were at least 50 stormtroopers standing there

188
Because I spotted a Jerba carrying a bunch of stuff at the festival site.

Cool, is that officially a jerba on Passana? The visual guide doesn't mention it. Theres a similar furry think on Kijimi. I cant really tell if those two are the same creatures though.

189
There were a number of ships in the Rebel fleet that were some nice easter eggs.  The ones I found?

The Rebel troop transport definitely had me puzzled.  It looks like a U-Wing cockpit on top of a big box, almost like the main hold of the Eravana (Han Solo's freighter at the beginning of TFA).

People have noted that Han's TFA freighter does appear to be in the low center of the shot.

Also this dude on twitter and his commentators have done quite a bit of work ID-ing ships. My questions here are about ships they have not yet addressed.
https://twitter.com/AdmiralNick22/status/1186349220757786629

190
The one circled in red looks like a U-wing to me.

yep, sorry. That one is labeled, sort of if you hash through my half-assed notation system.

191
I'm nerding out on the ships in the Allied Peoples Fleet (as I am calling it). I’m trying to ID Sidon Ithano’ s Meson Martinet based on the unaffiliated characters listed in the Visual Dictionary. The Martinet is a subject of confusion from various sources, which is noted on wookiepedia. The only full image of the ship was from the Lego game, which may or may not be official.

I’ve noted a few others from the visual dictionary that fly the type of ships pictured. Does anyone recognize the three mystery ships circled in orange, light green, and light blue? I selected those as candidates for the Meson Martinet.


192
Star Wars Ships and Vehicles / Custom TROS A-wing
« on: January 1, 2020, 02:04 AM »
Im looking to make a Custom green TROS A-wing out of the many extra TLJ a-wings I picked up.
Can anyone recommend a paint thinner that will work safely with modern hasbro plastic to strip of the blue paint.

193
TV-9D9 / Re: The Mandalorian (SPOILERS possible)
« on: December 31, 2019, 11:08 AM »
Nick, I totally misread your post the first time.  I thought you said IG-11 wiped them out.   :-[

My point was that there were a ton of new top of the line troopers that showed up with Moff Gideon, there were not a lot of Mandalorians in the covert....safe to assume they were overwhelmed.

I'm going to assume that Gideon had 2-3 times as many troops when he arrived as were left for episode 7&8. I can't believe it was easy to wipe out that many Mandos.

194
TV-9D9 / Re: The Mandalorian (SPOILERS possible)
« on: December 29, 2019, 01:09 PM »
Episode 8 was pretty rad.

I was kind of hoping Kuill would survive with injuries and it was just the Blurg that was blasted by the speeder bikes.

Did anyone catch the robocop reference in IG-11s base function? To Nurse and protect.

I realize this is the first live action of ground forces trying to take down a TIE but I thought Cara's gun would do more damage. I always had the impression that TIEs were pretty fragile. Maybe Gideon has shields added to his?

195
The Sequel Trilogy / Re: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker (SPOILERS)
« on: December 28, 2019, 05:20 PM »
Personally, I'd go with IMAX 2D over 3D....just because there's so much going on in several scenes that the #D could be really distracting.

Well I just tried the AMC imax.  As of now I can't tell a difference between that and the AMC Dolby screen right next to it.

Does it seem like Vader's helmet does anything in this trilogy? I'm assuming Palpatine was telling us that he "showed the darkness" to Kylo in what was assumed to be Vader. Kylo touches the helmet to try and mess with Rey while she's running the training course, but I assume the result is nothing more than the dyad connecting them. I aways felt weird about the idea of the helmet having any dark energy given Vader redeemed himself. When people say that Palpatine's return messes up Vader's sacrifice... I feel the helmet corrupting his grandson would have been exactly that. I don't agree that Palpatine returning affects Vader. Palpatine is an evil old **** and evil is as evil does. He returned in Dark empire and he returned here. If he had means to do so he would return.

I do like the idea of someone getting to surprise Palpatine twice only to have the second surprise backfire. The first surprise is the ability to transfer the saber from Rey to Ben. I appreciated the little slight of hand trick she does. The backfire surprise is that the life force of the two is enough to regenerate him, which it appears he did not anticipate.

Also, captain Sidon Ithano is present for the celebration at the end. He is listed in the visual dictionary  but it wasn't clear to me that was the connection. I'm hoping his ship the Meson Martinet is visible somewhere. Wookiepedia also claims that Quiggold is in ROS or maybe on set at least.

Pages: 1 ... 8 9 10 11 12 [13] 14 15 16 17 18 ... 21