Chris
Get the Jeep! I got one in December and it rocks. The 3 Piece "Freedom" top takes about 20 minutes to get off though.
This is not mine but exactly what it looks like.
The Sahara package (while not as Rugged and Pimp as the Rubicon) had a better feel on the road where I will spend most of the time in it for the first 3 years of it's life with me.
The only thing I would change is I would have gotten the "Dual" top instead of just the "3 piece Freedom top".
I love the fact it is the same color all over. Jeeps are very much like a Harley though, because I find myself wanting to customize it with badges and things and a brush guard/winch, light covers and lift kit and safari roof rack, snorkel and if possible an MG cupola (but only if they can color match the armor)
The thing I notice most in it is at highway speeds you really notice that you are driving something with a vertical windshield. I have a gruelling 5 mile commute so it is not a major thing.
F150's must be a Dallas thing, we are Silverado folks over here in Ft. Worth.
I don't know what the national numbers are but I know Pick Ups are the most stolen vehicles in N. Texas.