I guess I was just curious how come it made front page news when GG respectfully asked not to repost it. I'd think JD would "officially" want to respect that, on the front page anyway. The fact that you got the info secondhand and didn't know about the request not to repost it from Gentle Giant, I suppose makes it a lot more "ok".
I disagree with Josh simply because you're never going to be able to stop scalpers. We all see them at our local stores and we've all dealt with them. Some people may even know one. Posting the links on the page helped those who may not have even known about the collector's club/society. It didn't aid the scalpers cause I guarantee you they already are on that email list or have friends who alerted them as well.
I agree that it probably helped lots of collectors who wouldn't have otherwise known about it. I also agree that no one person can stop scalpers.
Still, the news broke on Rebelscum, and within a few hours the thread itself had 1000 views. I know EVERYONE who looked didn't buy one, but imagine if they did. That's half the run right there. Then add on to that any traffic the links on JD generated......that's a lot of people who may have not seen it otherwise.
I'm not saying don't tell your friends.
I'm not suggesting don't post the news.
I'm just saying that in the future, if GG asks not to post the link, maybe it would be cool to honor that so that the people who took the 5 seconds to join the collector's club truly get the first shot at these things.
I'd take the links down, but it's all water under the bridge at this point for those two...
Agreed. It's in the past, and I'm sure by now....every club member who wanted one already got one. They're still not sold out yet, and they're already up on Ebay....so whatever's going to happen has already happened.
