Well, it doesn't necessarily have to be new or unopened SW toys, and you don't HAVE to get something off of someone's want list. Folks are just posting those to give their Santas a hint as to what they're in the market for, or what type of stuff they collect.
Most people (who are openers) always love extra Clones, or army-builders, even if they're open. Heck, it doesn't even have to be Star Wars related. You could give gift cards, CDs, DVDs, books, whatever...
That help at all, S_A_?