VOTC 3PO in my opinion looked like the best 3PO,would you rather have a buff 3PO than a normal non-buff one?Also the Commtech Stormtrooepr was ok.
Of 3PO sculpts that exist, I think ONLY the POTF2 sculpt is worse than the VOTC (off the top of my head here)...
I prefer the following WAY over the VOTC sculpt:
-Vintage (ironically, it seems better to me in proportions)
-POTD 3-pack 3PO
-Rem. Limbs 3PO
-Tusken Attack 3PO (Flashback)
-ROTS 3PO
-Escape Pod 3PO (The sculpt is fantastic... Paint's so-so, but represents a dirty 3PO well)
-MMC 3PO (my favorite "Classic" 3PO at the moment, though the Ewok Throne one should replace this)
That's a pile I just think are better than VOTC... I just had my review of VOTC 3PO posted in my Review-A-Thon here last week, so check out the reviews section of our site here at JediDefender.com for my in-depth reasoning as to why VOTC 3PO sucks, but the short version is:
-Caved-in Chest
-Skinny scrawny sculpt
-pin-head with completely inaccurate detailing
-goofy, unnatural pose
The paintjob's not bad on him... Probably the most accurate one so far for a dirty ANH 3PO (not good for 3PO in ESB or ROTJ though). The pose I see where they were going with it, but it really ultimately fell flat... Mostly the "walking" legs kill it over the arms. I'll add to my sculpt dislike the fact that the arm pistons from the bicep to forearm aren't "separate" whereas they are on other figures and that looks better and more realistic. No C-3PO has that yet though,just R-3PO for some reason if I'm not mistaken.
And of course articulation's a mess on this overpriced figure... This C-3PO managed to have less articulation than a number of others when joints are easy to do on figures like this, they just require a pin & socket style of joint built into the figure...
Anyway, VOTC C-3PO is one of my all-time worsts I think... It's up there with Buff Fleet Trooper and Monkey Faced Leia for me. Just attrocious. Fortunately 3PO has a lot of versions of himself available to pick from that are better, just none are ever truly great... Even the Endor 3PO coming up isn't spectacular... Give him swivels at his biceps and wrist joints, and I'd sing some better praise on him I think.