I think AOTC Anakin and ROTS Anakin both look fantastic actually... As per our front page, here's some images of what I think the final product's going to look like while the shot shown before is the figures from C3 which weren't seemingly the "final" product.
I think the headsculpts on both look great in those pictures... Much truer to the actor than the hand-painted ones at C3 which can either be REALLY great or not too accurate.
I agree that ROTS Ani's robe poofs a bit, however I've never trusted displayed shots unless a collector did it.
I can get my VOTC Obi's cloak to lay better than any shot I ever saw, yet it still sorta bites. I'm thinking that, by the look of the fabric on ROS Ani, I can get the robe to lay better than the effort made in that picture.
The Vader, I think, had a removable helmet... It may just be another Vader, but if it's got a removable helmet and the ball/socket joints I'm thinking it has, it's going to blow the VOTC out of the water which is currently my #1...
I'm all for that!